By Stanley Rosen

Now to be had in paperback, The Quarrel among Philosophy and Poetry makes a speciality of the theoretical and sensible suppositions of the long-standing clash among philosophy and poetry. Stanley Rosen--one of the top Plato students of our day--examines philosophical job, wondering even if technical philosophy is a species of poetry, a political software, an interpretation of human life in response to the information of nineteenth and 20th-century thinkers, or a contemplation of beings and Being.

Show description

Read or Download The Quarrel Between Philosophy and Poetry: Studies in Ancient Thought PDF

Best Classical Studies books

Poetics (Penguin Classics)

Crucial studying for all scholars of Greek theatre and literature, and both stimulating for a person drawn to literature within the Poetics, his near-contemporary account of classical Greek tragedy, Aristotle study the dramatic parts of plot, personality, language and spectacle that mix to provide pity and worry within the viewers, and asks why we derive excitement from this it seems that painful technique.

Early Greek Philosophy (Penguin Classics)

The works gathered during this quantity shape the genuine beginning of Western philosophy—the base upon which Plato and Aristotle and their successors might ultimately construct. but the significance of the Pre-Socratics thinkers lies much less of their influence—great notwithstanding that was—than of their striking highbrow ambition and inventive succeed in.

Discourses and Selected Writings (Penguin Classics)

A brand new translation of the influential teachings of the good Stoic philosopherDESPITE BEING BORN into slavery, Greco-Roman thinker Epictetus turned some of the most influential thinkers of his time. Discourses and chosen Writings is a transcribed number of casual lectures given via the thinker round advert 108.

The Laws (Penguin Classics)

Within the legislation, Plato describes in attention-grabbing element a complete process of laws in a small agricultural utopia he named Magnesia. His legislation not just govern crime and punishment, but in addition shape a code of behavior for all elements of lifestyles in his excellent state—from schooling, recreation and faith to sexual behaviour, marriage and ingesting events.

Extra info for The Quarrel Between Philosophy and Poetry: Studies in Ancient Thought

Show sample text content

Within the Philebus, philosophical mathematics is related to review “what continues to be constantly an identical with no combination” (ta aei kata ta auta hōsautōs amiktotata echonta), and so as to supply “steadfast, natural, precise, and what we name unmixed” wisdom (59c2–6). yet human existence evidently belongs to these issues that experience end up, are coming to be, and should emerge as, that's, to the regularly altering or perishing, approximately which specific wisdom is very unlikely (58e4–59b3). It doesn't stick with that there's no wisdom of what is still continually an analogous. in addition, this data offers a type of skeleton to the residing and therefore vague wisdom of individual. however the skeleton isn't alive. In different phrases, human existence is just like the demiurgic a part of wisdom taken in its entirety, and never in any respect like philosophical mathematics. The latter might be marvelously better “in precision and fact” to the nonphilosophical arts (57c9–d2); yet for this very cause it isn't the “fitting” paradigm of the aspect in wisdom that ideas with appreciate to the criterion of the primary of the nice existence. Neither will we unravel the problem purely via substituting “sound judgment” (phronēsis), the paintings of the statesman, for the arithmetical artwork of the thinker, or (let us say) for the mathematical mind, that is dianoia, no longer nous understood as noēsis. The merchandising of phronēsis has to be observed by means of the popularity that the nice human lifestyles isn't, with the intention to converse, an “ontological” yet a demiurgic or poetic blend. Sound judgment can't rule other than via generating or developing an outstanding existence from the never-ending and forever various particularities of human lifestyles. the extreme edition of terminology, and the extraordinary confusion of the “arithmetical” articulation of steps within the argument, in addition to of the positions within the hierarchy, are dramatic illustrations of the inappropriateness of purity and precision as paradigmatic for the try and comprehend human existence. they're for this reason irrelevant because the paradigm for knowledge. actually that there's no unmarried or natural and detailed paradigm for knowledge, that's a divine blend, no longer an atomic aspect. we can't arrive at an exact or steadfast enumeration of the attributes of the great existence. to appreciate human lifestyles is to stay it, and therefore to provide or build the main points of the aggregate, whose parts may well fluctuate from one perspective to a different. something below this can be both platitude or sclerosis. as long as we take them of their traditional senses, there's a vital discontinuity among poetry and arithmetic. As an instantaneous outcome, if philosophy is represented via the paradigm of arithmetic, then it will possibly by no means win its quarrel with poetry. The victory is going to poetry, which directs arithmetic and offers it human importance. this is often the simplest stratum of Plato’s esoteric instructing; it's so to talk silently yet without delay conveyed through the very fact of the discussion. neither is the triumph of poetry a warrantly of political license and ontological relativism.

Rated 4.52 of 5 – based on 37 votes